This entry will make more sense if you have read at least the 2nd half of this website.

I was in Los Angeles in April of 2023. I visited with Melanie Myers from the 2014 Daily Mail story. She also appeared in the 2022 Secrets of Playboy documentary on the A&E channel.

During our interview, Melanie showed me an old piece of paper with phone numbers and names written on it. She had copied these from Paige’s personal phone directory after her suicide.

Melanie and B.J. Royale were preparing to share the task of calling Paige’s friends to tell them the news of her suicide.

And to tell them that Paige wanted them to have a certain of her paintings or other personal art objects.

Basically, a will.

B.J. Royale and Melanie lived in a duplex in front of Paige’s garage apartment in 1974.

The 3 shared a yard where Paige walked around nude or topless and Melanie “did not like it. ”

She added, “Paige and B.J. were pretty good friends,” but that she herself was not close with Paige.

Even so, Melanie said she ended up hearing an earful from Paige about a “sex tape” involving “Cici Huston‘s brother.” (David Shane)

B.J. Royale was a niece of actress Loretta Young, star of Hollywood films and TV in its’ Golden Age.

Royale, aka Betty J. Hermann, has a film credit for The Trouble with Angels, 1966. IMDB

This film was a box office hit. It stars Hayley Mills, a Disney actress. She was a bonafide box office star in the 1960s. I remember it shown on TV in the early 1970s.

Melanie made me a copy of her original notes and I took photos.

The names I saw on Paige’s phone list gave me clues and provide some insight into the last years of her life.

Melanie told me she met and knew Gretchen Foster due to knowing B.J.

Melanie had no idea that Paige had also known Gretchen.

Paige and BJ were fairly good friends, according to Melanie, so this must be the connection.

BJ Royale died a few years ago. She did not speak with the directors of Secrets of Playboy. I know they reached out to her.

Melanie said she got the impression that B.J. had zero interest in talking about Paige, and one reason may be that she “married and moved to Bakersfield where she was in high society.”

According to Melanie, Paige “willed a beautiful large pastel-colored painting, of horses,” to B.J. . But that Mrs. Hermann never wanted to talk about Paige.

Betty June was contacted by Secrets of Playboy. B.J. told them “I wasn’t there the weekend of the suicide.” And begged out of speaking on camera.

(I was told this by a researcher on the series. Too bad, because there was so much to ask Betty June besides the suicide weekend.)

This lady took whatever she knew, or remembered to her grave. Melanie and B. J. and Paige attended were at a Playboy mansion party together where they although Paige went separately.

Joni-(Hefner)

She is Hugh Hefner’s longtime assistant and personal secretary from the Chicago mansion days.

In my opinion, Joni Mattis took actions to “cover up” Paige’s suicide and scene and notes and letters left at her home, only a 10-minute car drive from the Playboy Mansion.

Perhaps Joni initiated the cover up by anticipating what Hef would want.

Another scenario is Joni contacted Hef and he told her what to do.

I can’t find out if Hefner was in the LA mansion on the dates of Paige’s suicide or in the Chicago mansion or somewhere else. Articles and Hollywood columns and Melanie’s story suggest he was present in the months leading up to Paige Young’s suicide and gave several parties. This was clear from items published in newspapers.

Joni and Hef/Playboy took actions. Their goal was to prevent the sensational news of Paige Young’s suicide from going anywhere near the press.

This action would have required cooperation from LAPD. Please see chapter of LAPD report and death certificate.

Melanie in Daily Mail-“police read some of the note to me… most vitriol for Hugh Hefner and John Huston.”

Melanie told me that that Paige’s mother (Donna) and sister (Constance) came the next day to pack up her belongings including paintings. “Connie” appears on Melanie’s list of phone numbers, identified as Paige’s sister. Melanie did not remember their names.

The Proximity Factor

Paige lived in Westwood, a 10 minute car drive to Holmby Hills. The local police had a friendly relationship with Hefner and the mansion employees.

Many former LAPD officers became Mansion security according to Secrets of Playboy. (PJ Masten) I believe Masten dated one of them at one time.

Hefner received reports on a regular basis from employees. They informed him about goings on at the mansion. This included employees and visitors, said PJ Masten.

The LAPD certainly knew who the hell Hugh Hefner was when they were greeted by Paige’s mural at her suicide scene 2 miles from the Playboy mansion.

As I continue to read about the history of the LAPD, I realize their Mythic status is based on historic facts. It has been a corrupt institution from the beginning. This fact is well expressed in the movie L.A. Confidential.

So really, it is not surprising that information unflattering to Hugh Hefner could be buried and made up to be like it just didn’t happen.

I am not in any way saying Hugh Hefner is directly responsible for Paige Young’s suicide.

But it is about the image.

Particularly at this date.

Bobbie Arnstein was arrested in Chicago, only 9 days before Paige’s suicide, on highly exaggerated cocaine charges.

Joni and Hef could have sincerely believed that by burying Paige’s story they were helping Bobbie and Hef from unjust prosecution. ( And persecution.)

There was more motivation than usual to justify hiding, burying and lying about Paige’s suicide (and everything she left behind incriminating Hugh Hefner, his friends and other men.)

PJ Masten in Secrets of Playboy talked about “an awareness that negative press was to be avoided.”

Jennifer Saginor, Secrets of Playboy and author of the book Playground said on a podcast Power,“Hef was always image conscious.” Hefner had the power to have Saginor’s book tour interviews suddenly canceled as she has recounted.

Jim Ellis, a former body guard for Hefner, early 1980s, said in Secrets of Playboy, his “job was not only protecting his clients physical being, but also their reputation.”

I believe that there was an opportunity for Playboy to shut this whole Paige Young thing down.

And the opportunity was quickly grabbed.

Hugh Hefner and Joni felt relieved I imagine.

Why does Paige Young’s entry in the Playmate Book, say “drug overdose” ?If they knowingly made that up, why that manner of death was chosen is beyond me.

END

The following screenshots are from a real estate website. They show the interior of Paige’s carriage house/apartment over a garage in Westwood. It is located down the street from the Mormon Temple. The apartment was built over a garage in 1940. It is where Paige lived the last years of her life. She committed suicide there. Among her belongings was a suicide note mentioning names she said were complicit in her downfall. There was also a will. A mural proclaimed “Hugh Hefner is the devil.” Her belongings included many of her paintings. A few unfinished. All her personal belongings.

These real estate photos are all the world has left of this particular place of what is “old Los Angeles.”

In this case, a carriage house over a garage. It was built in 1940 by Kathryn Eddy, who appeared in walk-on parts in silent movies.

Unless there are photographs lying in some attic or in a landfill placed decades ago?

All original built-ins, since gutted. Paige had a large black refrigerator a man bought for her and called it a “coffin,” said Melanie. This visit reminded me of another LA trip.

The place Paige was born as Diana Lee Cotterell is 1933 Griffith Park Blvd. It was originally a Christian Science Maternity center. The building was being torn down on the day I was visited. (See related chapter)

The builts-in of the 800 sq. foot apartment were being ripped out the day I visited; the place was being completely renovated.

The next section provides information on the Michael Butler entry found in Paige’s phone book. . Top right below sister Connie Smashey’s contact information.

I am confident he is the same Michael Butler most famous as the millionaire producer of Hair: the famous “Tribal Love Rock” musical.

Butler brought Hair to Broadway where it was a smash hit.

Dubbed by the media as a “hippie-millionaire”

A detailed description of Michael Butler and his upper crust background in the article below by Eugenia Sheppard. It appeared in newspapers across the country in 1968, the year Hair opened. Also the year Paige Young was a Vietnam–era Playboy Playmate.

Page #3 of the LAT article. Butler was and avid polo player and played the sport with the wealthy elite around the world. Including Santa Barbara County as seen in the next articles.

http://www.michaelbutler.com

Last I checked, this Butler website was being maintained well. You can see the entry about his good friend Celeste Huston.

Celeste Shane Huston and Paige Young had 5 people in common: John Huston, Bill Gardner, Samson DeBrier, David Shane and Michael Butler.

Nothing comes up for Gus Prall at the top left.

Note below that David Shane is listed right below a Geo. Roberts on the left hand column, an X through it.

Shane is an important character from several other chapters. He was a man with a large 1970s mustache like Michael Butler, business owner set up by his successful Beverly Hills rental car owner father, and the brother of Cici Shane (Mrs.John) Huston.

Shane was a visitor to the LA Mansion and possible holder or keeper, and partner in Paige’s “sex tape.”

See chapters with Shane in the title, and Secrets of Playboy, episode 8.

Playboy Club Move announcement, and for the Classic Cat Performance of Cabaret and A mexican restaurant actually named speedy Gonzales.

Marty Tregman is a long time realtor in Santa Monica, he doesn’t remember Paige. Jon Von Newman…. came up with nothing. Brian Wilson is a common name so I can’t say this with the genius writer of the Beach Boys music group.

And right below Brian Wilson,

I was intrigued with the entry “Feminist Women’s Health Center 746 Crenshaw”

And I found many articles in the newspaper archives.

Quote below from Los Angeles Conservancy, an historic architecture preservation society.

It is from their website as part of their nomination for historic status of the FWHC building at 1027 Crenshaw.

“Women’s Self-Help One clinic was the first in the nation and consequently placed the Crenshaw Women’s Center at the genesis point of the women’s self-help movement. Founded by Carol Downer and Lorraine Rothman, the clinic became a model for the national movement. In 1972, the Center was raided by police. Ms. Downer had applied yogurt as a cure for a yeast infection and was arrested for practicing medicine without a license.  She was acquitted and the platform and publicity of The Great Yogurt Conspiracy raised the consciousness of the nation and helped make woman’s clinics a national movement.”

Historic status was denied.

The raid happened at 1027 Crenshaw Now I am not so sure. Press articles give the address as 746 Crenshaw as seen below. I am now thinking both locations were raided.

Screen shot from Summer of 2024 of 1026 Crenshaw.

The Great Yogurt Conspiracy received wide press coverage due to its’ humorous title and the absurdity of the charges. This article explains more what it is:

“Carol Downer revolutionized the women’s health movement, learning how to perform abortions and vaginal self-examinations, and teaching other women how to, as well. From the website Feminist Current, an interview with Carol Downer conducted about 3 years ago.

The “yogurt conspiracy,” arrest and acquittal caught the attention of cultural icons like Gloria Steinem, Bella Abzug and Dr. Benjamin Spock, bringing national attention to the LA activists.

  “Lorraine Rothman was a founding member of the feminist centered Self-Help Clinic movement and a major mover of many successful behind-the-scenes projects. With Carol Downer, she worked on the concept of menstrual extraction as a viable women’s home health care technique; and, in 1971, she invented the Del-Em menstrual extraction kit, which was patented n 1974……… Rothman’s collaborative relationship with Downer and the self-help clinic movement began when she attended an April 7, 1971 meeting organized by Downer to discuss women’s reproductive rights and abortion. At the second meeting, one week later, Rothman shared her idea of a safe home health care tool, demonstrating the prototype of the Del-Em menstrual extraction kit. Shortly afterwards, Downer and Rothman founded the Feminist Women’s Health Center (FWHC) in Los Angeles; Rothman went on to open a second FWHC in Orange County, closer to her home and family. Over the next two decades, Rothman traveled widely, taking the Self-Help Clinic concept to women’s groups both in and outside the US....”Archived interview subject description at CSU Long Beach.

746 Crenshaw, the address Paige had in her phone book, location was demolished in the 1980s and replaced with this monstrosity.

Carol Downer continues to lives in Eagle Rock and has been working in disability and immigration law for many years. She has lived a life of activism in women’s reproductive rights and the international peace movement.

She believes that women should not depend on the current legal status of a woman’s right to an abortion. .

Downer still advocates for women to learn the self-care or self-help method of abortion. She wrote a book on the topic in the 1990s.

For more details, see the Carol Downer entry in the Embryo Project Encyclopedia.

END

Veronica remembers buying groceries for Paige, at a store located at the bottom of “Fernwood & Topanga Canyon Dr.”

And the Safeway on Sunset & PCH, later Vons.

This happened about once a month for quite a while. The “2 friends would chit chat and catch up on news.” Paige never wanted more food than she could physically carry.

This was before her move to Westwood. After that Veronica didn’t see Paige as much but they talked often on the phone.

She remembers just vaguely that Paige mentioned her about her own art studio in Venice Beach, a block away from the beach. (See 2 chapters: Venice Beach, Richard Sample.)

(Dennis Hopper has a connection to Paige as he knew the artists that Paige knew, Larry Bell and in the same building: DeWain Valentine. Robert Irwin lived across the street at this time in Venice. Veronica remembers Hopper at events around town)

Paige sometimes expressed her suicide ideation in phone conversations with Veronica.

She did not discuss Hugh Hefner or John Huston, David Shane, Desmond Guinness or a”sex tape.”(See related chapters)

Several times Paige needed a ride to visit her sister, but Veronica never met the sister: Constance/Connie.

The last time the friends had a phone conversation, Veronica noted an “echoey sound in the background, sounded like Paige was in a bathroom.” Veronica tried to lighten the mood by asking her about the echoey sound and said,”Paige are you already in heaven?” Paige laughed and they hung up the phone with Veronica feeling Paige was in a better space.

Paige one time had checked herself into the UCLA Psych Center but was released in a just a few days.

Once Paige told Veronica “she said she had cured all the patients at the ward.”

Veronica said she never believed that Paige would actually go through with suicide.

Separately, Melanie told me about one time driving Paige to the UCLA Psych Ward. She remembers Paige “returning from the ward with a very strange man who worked at the hospital.”

He lunged at Melanie, Paige suddenly appeared with a gun and he bolted. Without pants on she said and added “it was the same gun she used on herself.”

Paige probably took advantage of the 51/50 law, which began in California in 1967.

“In California we have a law (5150) that the police (or yourself if you may harm yourself) can commit you for 3 days to a hospital for psych care.  If you are pronounced no longer liable to harm yourself or others or decide you want to leave  voluntarily you can after three days.”

Veronica does remember Paige’s expressing she did not have enough money for paint.

She told her to just wait a few days and would help her out with that.

Paige was dead before that happened.

Lack of money was a recurring problem for Paige.

She did not know Paige to own a car, says Veronica.

Paige did not talk of her past or any future plans. She seemed to always exist and speak in the present moment.

Melanie said does not remember Paige owning a car.

I personally think Paige sold her yellow Mustang seen by Sample in Malibu 64-67. Also seen by her cousin Christian/Chris in Sherman Oaks in 1964 as described to me. Paige made Chris a cup of coffee during his visit to her apartment. She told him about her divorce from Mark F. Segal.

Paige did not mention the violence and threats I viewed in her divorce papers. I told Chris about and he said “Oh, she would not have put up with that.”

No one I’ve communicated with who knew Paige say they can remember a time when she talked about her childhood. She never mentioned her family or her background. Veronica says Joe Rank may have known something of Paige’s family members.

Chris said he and his mother were contacted by Connie Smashey, Paige’s sister, to tell them the bad news of Paige’s suicide. Chris told me that Connie had a seemingly indifferent attitude about Paige’s death and he got the impression of “good riddance.” Chris said this made he and his mother sick to their stomach and angry and they did not stay in touch with Connie.

Aca Joe History

“Joe Rank, a Los Angeles broadcasting executive who had managed KMEX-TV, the Spanish language TV station in Los Angeles, moved to Mexico in 1973 to establish a printed tee shirt business on the beach resorts which were booming with international tourism. By 1978, Rank had shops in 75 stores in Acapulco, Cancun, Puerto Vallarta, Mazatlán, and Mexico City, plus tee shirt shops in 15 of the popular Carlos n’ Charlie’s bars and restaurants throughout Mexico.

In 1983, the name was changed to Aca Joe and product distribution was limited only to Aca Joe owned or franchised stores. The line was expanded to include pants, jackets, sweaters, and more than just tee shirts. After changing to this more exclusive distribution of the product, the stores were swamped with customers. Lines were formed in front of the stores with people waiting to get in at all hours of the day.

The success of Aca Joe did not go without notice by international investors, and soon a deal was made with American partners for the expansion of Aca Joe outside of Mexico. William Meyer became Rank’s partner in Aca Joe International and the first stores in the U.S. were opened in the Bay Area of San Francisco, with shops in Union Square, Sausalito, and the Stanford Shopping Center.

The U.S. shops were very successful, and to provide financing for expansion, the new U.S. company filed for listing on the NASDAQ stock exchange. Prospects for the future of the stores were bright, and in 1985 Aca Joe International was the fastest rising stock on NASDAQ” From the ACA Joe website.

Joe left LA and had moved to Mexico in 1973, before Paige killed herself.

Below are some photos of Paige’s over-a-garage apartment and where she stage her death.

Away from the backyard and duplex.